Product Recall Mitigation Strategies
This page focuses on pre-recall planning — the resilience you build before a recall ever happens. If you are managing an active recall right now, see our companion page, Recall Lawyer for Food Products, for active-recall response.
Food product recalls are monstrously expensive. Most obviously, food businesses have a sunk cost in the value of the ingredients in the jar or package being recalled, which commonly end up in a landfill. Additional costs are incurred during the recall itself: stock has to be taken off shelves, boxed again, and shipped back to the manufacturer; unsellable product has to be stored, catalogued to determine the effectiveness of the recall, then carted off for disposal. For all but the largest businesses, recall expenses are an existential threat.
How Can a Business Mitigate Recall Risk?
Several of the services listed on our service pages can be used to mitigate recall risk. These services have a cumulative effect and achieve their maximum impact when combined.
- A compliance audit of all packaged food product labeling can reduce the risk of recalls caused by misbranding or undeclared allergens.
- Assess the “worst-case scenario” by analyzing how a food product is used by its purchasers. Defective products used as ingredients in other manufactured foods can contaminate the final product, causing a cascade of recalls that increase in size. Calculating the worst case guides the resources allocated to prevention and mitigation.
- Food safety plans should be regularly reviewed and rigorously adhered to. There is no such thing as a superfluous investment in food safety; we work closely with an excellent food safety specialist who can build and monitor superb food safety plans.
- Input suppliers should warranty that they have accurately declared the allergens in the ingredients the manufacturer depends on.
- Co-packers should be contractually obligated to indemnify and hold harmless you and your product for any recall precipitated by their negligence. These terms can be addressed in co-packer agreements.
- The cost of purchasing recall insurance should be delegated to co-packers if possible. If a food business cannot negotiate this term, it is almost always advisable to purchase recall insurance for itself.
- Run a recall drill with staff at least once a year. The quicker a harmful product can be pulled off shelves, the fewer liabilities you will have.
It is impossible to fully insulate a food business from the consequences of a recall. We can only create resiliency through comprehensive risk management that permeates the business’s culture, its commercial agreements, and its food safety practices.
Recall-Readiness Checklist: Are You FSMA-Ready?
FSMA — the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act — is the moment most food companies discover they need a written recall plan. Use this pre-recall checklist to gauge your readiness. If you cannot produce these documents today, you are not recall-ready:
- A written recall plan that names a Recall Committee and assigns roles before a crisis.
- Up-to-date lot/code traceability one step forward and one step back through your supply chain.
- A worst-case-scenario analysis for each product based on how it is used downstream.
- Allergen-declaration warranties from every ingredient supplier.
- Indemnification and hold-harmless clauses in every co-packer and supplier agreement.
- Recall insurance in force, with responsibility for premiums assigned by contract where possible.
- A current food safety plan that is actually reviewed, not just filed.
- A recall drill completed within the last 12 months, with after-action notes.
Working through this list before an event is the entire point of recall mitigation. When a recall does happen, the work shifts to active response — that is where our recall lawyers step in.
Fractional General Counsel: one flat fee, continuous coverage
Recall plans are not “set and forget” — they need annual updates, fresh drills, and contract refreshes as suppliers and co-packers change. Our Fractional General Counsel subscription folds this work into one predictable monthly fee instead of billing you per matter — the same in-house legal backing a much larger company would carry, sized for a growing food and beverage brand. Compare Service Plans →
Last reviewed: June 2026
Jason Foscolo
Founder of The Food Law Firm — fractional general counsel for food & beverage businesses nationwide.
Our subscription service
Clients realize the greatest value out of our services when they stack them together comprehensively. Our subscription-based service plans enable our clients to weave our services into the fabric of their businesses at affordable and predictable rates.
